. . .

About This Site

Cooperstown Cred is primarily focused on the credentials of current or potentially future candidates for the ultimate honor in sport, induction into the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.

As the Hall of Fame debate is by definition an exercise of comparative analysis, of course we also take a look at exising Hall of Fame members.

The content on Cooperstown Cred contains a blend of sabermetric and comparative analysis with old-school thinking. WAR (Wins Above Replacement) is not the be-all everything statistic but it’s important: it’s an indicator that points us towards further study. In the meantime, we still give a batter credit for his RBI and a starting pitcher for his Wins. Remember, it’s the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of WAR.

The articles here are designed to appeal to both the old-school fan but also those who like to take a deep dive into the numbers.

Most of the statistics on this site are the ones you grew up with but there are some new ones that we’ve embraced. In particular, OPS+ and ERA+ give us the ability to compare players from different ballparks and different eras across history. For the limited number of advanced metrics like those that we use, there’s often a link in the piece to explain and you can always look in the Glossary, many categories of which are featured in the sidebar on the right of the page.

The author, Chris Bodig, a longtime enthusiast of the Hall of Fame since first visiting at the age of 13 in 1980, is a former Producer for ESPN’s Baseball Tonight and Coordinating Producer for Up Close.

Blog Stats

  • 1,245,520 site visits. Thanks for visiting Cooperstown Cred.

Featured Articles

Articles Posted or Updated from 2021 to 2026:

Remembering Mickey Lolich (1940-2026)

Carlos Beltran, Postseason Star, Makes the Hall of Fame

Andruw Jones, Defensive Whiz, Finally Makes the Hall of Fame

Carlos Beltran and Andruw Jones are Elected to the Hall of Fame

Cooperstown Cred 2026 Virtual Hall of Fame Ballot

Does Chase Utley Have a Hall of Fame Case?

Felix Hernandez: Future King of Cooperstown?

The Complicated Hall of Fame Case of Andy Pettitte

Does Dustin Pedroia Deserve a Plaque in the Hall of Fame

Don’t Laugh: the Hall of Fame Case for Bobby Abreu

The Cooperstown Candidacy for Mark Buehrle

Spider-Man: Does Torii Hunter Have a Hall of Fame Case?

The One and Dones on the 2026 Ballot: Matt Kemp, Alex Gordon, Hunter  Pence, Nick Markakis, Shin-Soo Choo

The One and Dones on the 2026 Ballot: Edwin Encarnacion, Daniel Murphy, Howie Kendrick, Rick Porcello, Gio Gonzalez

David Wright: Cooperstown Cred for Mr. Met

The Hall of Fame Case for and Against Jimmy Rollins

The Polarizing Hall of Fame Case of Omar Vizquel

Is There a Hall of Fame Case for Francisco Rodriguez?

Ryan Braun is on the Hall of Fame Ballot

The Hall of Fame Case for and against Cole Hamels

Jeff Kent: the First Member of the Hall of Fame’s Class of 2026

Gary Sheffield Gets Another Shot at the Hall of Fame

Dale Murphy, Superstar from the 1980s, is Back on the Hall of Fame Ballot

Should Don Mattingly be in the Hall of Fame?

Carlos Delgado is on the Hall of Fame Ballot

Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are Back on the Hall of Fame Ballot

The Late Fernando Valenzuela is on the Era Committee Hall of Fame Ballot

RIP Davey Johnson (1943-2025)

Remembering Ryne Sandberg (1959-2025)

Ichiro Suzuki’s Uniquely Superb Hall of Fame Career

CC Sabathia: First Ballot Hall of Famer

The Hall of Fame Finally Opens Its Doors to Billy Wagner

Dick Allen is Finally Elected to the Hall of Fame

RIP Hall of Famer Dave Parker (1951-2025): the COBRA Dies at 74

Clayton Kershaw’s 3,000th K puts a Cherry on his Hall of Fame Sundae

40 Years Ago: Gary Carter’s Opening Day at Shea

Ichiro Suzuki, CC Sabathia, and Billy Wagner are Elected to the Hall of Fame

Cooperstown Cred 2025 Virtual Ballot

The One and Dones on the 2025 BBWAA Ballot

RIP Mr. Baseball: Bob Uecker (1934-2025)

Can a Hall of Fame Case be Framed for Brian McCann?

RIP Rickey Henderson (1958-2024), Baseball’s Greatest Leadoff Hitter

Ian Kinsler: Long-Shot Hall of Fame Candidate

The Legend of Negro League Star John Donaldson

The Hall of Fame Case for Vic Harris, Managerial Legend of the Negro Leagues

Ken Boyer: Underappreciated Star, Hall of Fame Candidate

Should Tommy John be Known as a Hall of Famer, not just a Surgical Procedure?

Clean Slate: Steve Garvey is Still Hoping for the Hall of Fame Call

RIP Luis Tiant (1940-2024): a Tribute to El Tiante

Freddie Freeman’s Hall of Fame Moment

Remembering Fernando Valenzuela: 1960-2024

Jim Leyland is Elected to the Hall of Fame

Todd Helton Closes the Coors Field Hall of Fame Debate

Former Twins Catcher Joe Mauer is in the Hall of Fame

Adrian Beltre: Hall of Fame Class of 2024

RIP Orlando Cepeda (1937-2024)

Say Hey: RIP Willie Mays (1931-2024)

Adrian Beltre, Joe Mauer, and Todd Helton are Elected to the Hall of Fame

Cooperstown Cred Virtual Ballot: 10 Picks for 2024

The One-and-Dones on the 2024 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot

The Hall of Fame Case for Bill White

Should Sweet Lou Piniella Be in the Hall of Fame?

Davey Johnson’s Managerial Career and Cooperstown Credentials

Bruce Bochy Puts a Cherry on His Cooperstown Sunday with His 4th World Championship

RIP Frank Howard: 1936-2023

RIP Brooks Robinson: 1937-2023

Scott Rolen’s Path to the Hall of Fame: a WAR Story

Cooperstown Justice: Fred McGriff is Getting Inducted into the Hall of Fame

The Hall of Fame Case for Mel Stottlemyre (by James Beemer)

RIP Vida Blue: 1949-2023

Scott Rolen is Elected to the Hall of Fame

Cooperstown Cred Virtual Ballot for 2023: The Author’s 10 Picks

What to do about Alex Rodriguez and the Hall of Fame?

Will Manny Ramirez Ever be Manny in Cooperstown

First-Time Candidates on the 2023 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot

Rafael Palmeiro is on the Hall of Fame Ballot Again

RIP Gaylord Perry (1938-2022): Cooperstown Spitballer, Allegedly

Peak Performance: Albert Belle’s Hall of Fame Case

Forget Politics: Curt Schilling Belongs in the Hall of Fame

2023 Contemporary Baseball Players Ballot Announced

Dusty Baker Finally Gets His Ring, Clinches the Hall of Fame

Win or Lose, Dusty Baker Will be in the Hall of Fame

Justin Verlander’s Inexorable March Towards the Hall of Fame

Perennially Underrated, the Hall of Fame Case for Dwight Evans

Hall of Fame Chances for Bryce Harper, now a Two-Time MVP

RIP Bruce Sutter: Split-Fingered Pioneer (1953-2022)

Has Yadier Molina Successfully Framed his Hall of Fame Case?

Appreciating Albert Pujols’ Hall of Fame Career

RIP Maury Wills (1932-2022)

Max Scherzer Adds Another Milestone to His Hall of Fame Resume

Tributes to Vin Scully (1927-2022)

David Ortiz: An Obvious Hall of Famer

Why Jim Kaat Deserves His Plaque in the Hall of Fame

Minnie Minoso Makes it to Cooperstown

35th Time a Charm: Gil Hodges has been Elected to the Hall of Fame

After Decades of Waiting, Tony Oliva is Elected to the Hall of Fame

From 1977 to 2022: The All-Star Game

Why Keith Hernandez Belongs in the Hall of Fame

Miguel Cabrera Joins the Exclusive 3,000/500 Club

Will Sweet Lou Whitaker Join Alan Trammell in the Hall of Fame?

David Ortiz: Lone BBWAA Inductee to the Hall of Fame Class of 2022

Cooperstown Cred 2022 Virtual Ballot

Joe Nathan and the Cooperstown Closer Conundrum

Sammy Sosa Ends his BBWAA Balloting Far Away from Cooperstown

The Hall of Fame Case for and against Tim Hudson

Kaat, Oliva, Among Six Hall of Famers Elected by the Eras Committees

Hall of Fame Eras Committee Vote Preview and Predictions

The Hall of Fame Case For and Against Danny Murtaugh

First-Time Candidates on the 2022 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot

Should Roger Maris have a Plaque in the Hall of Fame

David Ortiz’s Greatest Postseason Hits

Billy Pierce: Star from the 1950s, on the Hall of Fame Ballot

Buster Posey Retires: What are his Hall of Fame Chances?

Ichiro Suzuki’s Uniquely Superb Hall of Fame Career

Bernie Williams: Should the Great Yankee be in the Hall of Fame?

Derek Jeter’s Career Filled with Hall of Fame Moments

Larry Walker Elected to the Hall of Fame, Overcoming Coors Field Bias

Ted Simmons: Finally in the Hall of Fame

Marvin Miller: Cooperstown’s Greatest Snub No More

Wally Schang: 3-time World Series Champion Backstop, not in the Hall of Fame

Does Jorge Posada Deserve a Closer Look at the Hall of Fame?

Mike Trout, Now 30, Already a Future Hall of Famer

Cobra: Will Dave Parker Have Another Chance to Strike at Cooperstown?

Johan Santana: a Hall of Fame of Peak Value

Dustin Pedroia Retires: Will he Make the Hall of Fame?

Tributes to Hank Aaron (1934-2021), Forever the Home Run King

RIP Tommy Lasorda, the Big Dodger in the Sky